Fourth Grade - ELA
1: Interdependence
Unit 1: Little House in the Big Woods
Lesson 3
Winter Days and Winter Nights
Students are asked to answer and discuss why the family made their own butter and ate animals from the woods (QUESTION #2), which requires identifying the reason given in the text (remoteness/no store). Students are prompted to discuss why a person's home is important and why every family member must help out on the homestead, asking them to state reasons for those points. QUESTION #4 asks students to identify words or phrases the author used to make a story more exciting, which has students locate textual evidence to support an interpretive point. Students write answers in a journal and speak in a discussion, providing opportunities to express reasons and supporting details.
Lesson 4
The Long Rifle
Students are asked to retell aloud the story Pa told the girls and to answer why Pa might have made his own bullets and why he told the cattle story, which prompts them to state reasons. Students are instructed to discuss how a professional storyteller got the audience's attention and why people wanted to listen, which asks them to identify reasons for audience response. Students prepare and share oral stories and are asked to identify (with assistance) purpose and audience for an oral presentation, connecting to evaluating a speaker's goals.
Lesson 6
Sundays and Two Big Bears
Students answer direct "why" questions about the chapters (e.g., "Why did Laura and Mary dislike Sundays?" and questions about Pa's actions and the moral of Pa's story), which requires stating reasons drawn from the text. The skills and activities ask students to share written and oral products and to read poems aloud, providing opportunities for students to listen to and speak about text-based points. The bear research and fact/opinion activities require students to collect and record factual information, which can serve as evidence for points they make.
Lesson 7
The Sugar Snow
Students are asked to answer several 'why' questions (e.g., QUESTION #1: Do you think Laura was happy to see the new snow? Why or why not?; QUESTION #3: Why did Pa call the snow a sugar snow?) that require giving reasons based on text. Students are prompted to summarize the chapter and to discuss how pioneers used natural resources, which requires explaining supporting details. The skills section asks students to use oral and written language to present information and to discuss and sustain conversation on a topic, and Activity 3 asks students to record or sequence the steps Grandpa took to make maple syrup, requiring students to identify supporting procedural evidence.
Lesson 11
Finishing the Book
Students read aloud and respond to an author's letter and are asked whether the letter is formal or informal and why (student is prompted to give a reason: "It is more formal because she is writing to the public"). Students answer several "why" questions about chapters (e.g., why Pa didn't shoot the deer or bear, why Mary and Laura held hands) that require identifying reasons for characters' actions as stated or implied in the text.
Final Project
Pioneer Family Night
Students are asked to explain how pioneers were dependent on natural resources when leading the orange clove craft and to discuss that dependence with their family. Students must read aloud two to three favorite sections and explain why those sections are their favorites, and they must explain the importance of music, dance, and storytelling to the pioneers. Students are instructed to lead family activities and take notes, and to let other family members take turns telling stories.
Unit 2: The Sign of the Beaver
Lesson 4
A Treaty
Students are asked to answer Question #4: "How do you think Attean felt about Matt? What evidence do you have?" which requires students to identify evidence supporting a particular point. The lesson also includes discussion prompts (e.g., "She can discuss the remaining questions with you" and "Discuss that because Matt is hurt, he is going to be dependent on the Indians…") that ask students to explain reasons for interdependence and to articulate why Saknis wanted Attean to learn to read (Question #8).
Lesson 5
A Story
The lesson asks students to explain why characters respond as they do (questions 2, 5, and 7 ask students to give reasons for Attean's and Matt's reactions). The 'Past and Present' journal activity asks students to think about why Matt identifies with Robinson Crusoe and why Attean reacts strongly to Friday, requiring students to state reasons tied to characters' experiences. Several discussion prompts ask students to compare perspectives and reflect on how personal experiences influence understanding, which asks students to articulate reasons for viewpoints.
Lesson 12
Persuasive Writing
Students are asked to list advantages for both choices (Activity 1), which requires them to generate reasons for each side. Students must write a letter or speech that includes "the three best reasons" and "provide support for each reason" (Activity 2). The rubric explicitly asks students if they provide three reasons and if they provide support for all three reasons, prompting students to produce reasons and supporting evidence in their speech.
Unit 3: Native American Animal Stories
Lesson 1
Myths, Legends, and Folktales
Students listen to an adult tell a myth, legend, or folktale and are asked why they protest when the story is paused and which parts entertained them, prompting them to identify storytelling techniques (voices, gestures, suspense) that produced effects. Students are asked to explain why Native American stories emphasize nature and to identify elements of culture from myths by recording Transportation, Housing, Food, Activities/Entertainment, Religion, and other cultural details on the Elements of Culture page. Students retell the story after listening, demonstrating comprehension of the speaker's points about plot and cultural content.
2: Force and Power
Unit 1: Ben and Me
Lesson 2
Setting the Record Straight
Students read Chapters 1–2 and answer a journal question asking, 'Why did Amos decide to write his account of Ben Franklin's life?', which requires them to identify Amos's reasons. Students practice determining point of view and use the 'Fact and Fiction' chart to record factual and fictional events from each chapter, prompting them to evaluate claims and supporting details in the narrative. Students also quote sentences from the book when recording vocabulary words, linking specific text passages to their written responses.
Lesson 4
Electricity
Students answer comprehension questions that require them to identify reasons given in dialogue and events (e.g., Question #1 asks why Ben was interested in printing; Question #3 asks why an angry mob came; Question #4 asks how Franklin calmed the mob and cites his assurance). The Skills section and Wrapping Up prompt students to retell and verbally summarize spoken messages from the chapters. Activity questions (e.g., Q2 and Q7) ask students to explain motives or infer how a speaker would finish a sentence, which engages with speakers' points.
Lesson 5
Electrifying
The lesson asks the child to participate in discussions using remaining chapter questions and includes several 'why' prompts (e.g., "Why do you think Ben thought it was important...," "Why did Ben give up his scientific investigation...?") that require students to state reasons. The Wrapping Up section directs the child to discuss how Franklin exerted power over Amos and whether that was fair, prompting students to give and hear reasons and judgments. The student activity page for the lightning experiment asks "Why do you think this happened?", requiring students to provide an explanation based on evidence from the activity.
Lesson 6
War
Students are asked in the Wrapping Up section to explain why the colonists went to war and to discuss the problems the colonists had, which prompts them to state reasons for a historical action. Activity 3 (Fact and Opinion) requires students to mark statements as fact or opinion and to record two facts and two opinions that Amos shares, which has students identify claims made by a narrator. Reading-and-questions items (for example, "Why did Ben travel to France? How do you think France could help the colonists?") ask students to articulate causes and possible supporting reasons from the text.
Lesson 9
The Rescue
Question #3 asks students to explain how Amos proved he had "vision," which requires students to identify supporting evidence from the text. The Fact and Fiction activity asks students to select a factual event and a fictional event from the chapters, prompting them to distinguish evidence-based events from fictional ones. In the Ben and Amos Bags activity students place items that represent each character and are asked to explain the significance of each item and how it relates to the character, requiring them to cite details from Amos's account.
Lesson 10
Back Home
Students answer discussion questions that ask "Why?" (e.g., whether Amos should stay with Ben and whether the birthday gift was good), which requires them to state reasons for their positions. Students interview adults to collect each adult's interpretation of Ben's maxims, requiring students to listen and record others' viewpoints. Students fill the "Elements of Historical Fiction" page by providing events or characters that support each element, practicing identification of evidence from the text to support a particular point.
Final Project
An Interview or Party for Ben
Students write ten interview questions and answer them in character as Ben Franklin, which requires them to state reasons or explanations for his actions (for example, how he used his power and influence or how his inventions changed culture). Students write and explain two of Ben's maxims and describe why each maxim has been important, which asks them to provide supporting explanation for a point. Students practice and present the interview aloud to an audience, speaking the answers that include his accomplishments and justifications.
Unit 2: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe
Lesson 2
Edmund Discovers Narnia
The lesson asks students to explain character motives (Question #4: "What was the queen's attitude toward Edmund when she met him? Why do you think she changed her tone?") and to infer intentions (Question #6: why the queen wants Edmund to come). Activity 2, Option 2 asks students to write a paragraph describing how the witch would try to convince them to eat a favorite food and to think about what words and descriptions the witch would use to persuade. The Good vs. Evil chart asks students to record examples of the struggle and to explain how evil is trying to gain power or how good is responding.
Lesson 3
Always Winter and Never Christmas
Students read and discuss the Professor's spoken logic when he says, "There are three possibilities... we must assume she is telling the truth," and Question #2 asks how the Professor responded, prompting students to identify his reasoning. The Activity 2 'Narnia Logic' worksheet has students read sets of statements (premises) and decide whether the conclusion is logical, requiring them to evaluate the reasons given. The lesson directs discussion and journal responses about characters' claims and the Professor's argument, giving students opportunities to identify support for particular points.
Lesson 8
Deep Magic
Students answer and discuss text-dependent questions that ask them to explain why events occurred (for example, questions asking why the White Witch said Edmund was hers, why people acted quietly after the meeting, and why the witch killed Aslan). Students are asked to justify opinions (e.g., whether Edmund should have been rescued) and to record facts and reasons on activity pages (such as listing how a chosen historical leader used power and deciding if the leader was like Aslan or the White Witch). The teacher/parent is also directed to reread a passage aloud for the imagery activity, providing an opportunity for students to listen and respond to spoken text.
Lesson 9
Back to Life
Students are asked to report what Aslan told the girls about the witch not knowing that a willing, innocent victim killed in a traitor's place would make the Table crack and cause Death to work backward (Question #4), which requires identifying a speaker's explanation. Students are prompted to answer "Why do you think this happened?" about the Stone Table (Question #2), which asks them to state reasons for an event. The discussion instruction ("use the remaining questions in a discussion") and Activity 2 (describe three ways Aslan resembles a Christ-like figure using the provided traits) ask students to give and support points orally or in writing using textual evidence.
Unit 3: The BFG
Lesson 2
Snatched
Students are asked to answer comprehension questions that require giving reasons, for example Q3: "Do you think the giant is a powerful character? If yes, why? If no, why not?", which prompts students to state and support a claim. Students locate and copy the author's description of the setting (Option 2) and use that text to illustrate the environment, demonstrating use of textual details as support. The skills section explicitly lists "Use text to locate information for specific purposes," which directs students to find and use evidence from the text.
Lesson 3
The BFG
Students answer comprehension questions that require identifying reasons characters give (e.g., Question #4 asks why the BFG said he had to take Sophie: students identify his reason that she saw him and would tell everyone, risking a giant hunt). Question #3 asks how giants use size and power and how the BFG is different, prompting students to state the giants' actions (capture and eat people) and the BFG's refusal to eat people. The wrapping-up prompts ask students to explain why the BFG did not want to exert his power, and the Quotable Quotes activity asks students to locate and record exact words spoken by Sophie and the BFG that could serve as evidence.
Lesson 5
Time with the BFG
Question #1 asks students to identify what the BFG told the Bloodbottler to get him to eat the snozzcumber (answer: he told him it tasted delicious), which has students note a speaker's stated reason. Activity 1 directs students to identify and record quotes from Sophie and the BFG, giving students practice locating speakers' words that could serve as evidence. The discussion prompt comparing how the Bloodbottler and the BFG use power asks students to discuss differences in behavior and motivations, which could lead students to cite dialogue or actions as support.
Lesson 6
Catching People and Dreams
Students are asked to answer comprehension/discussion questions that require reporting a speaker's claims or explanations (e.g., Q4 asks how the giants avoid an outcry, Q5 asks how the giant challenged Sophie's belief, and Q6 asks how the giant describes humans hurting one another). The Interpreting the BFG activity has students translate and correct the giant's language so they must determine the giant's intended meaning. The Quotable Quotes activity has students identify and record direct quotes from Sophie and the BFG that could serve as evidence for points the characters make.
Lesson 7
A Nightmare for Fleshlumpeater
Students are asked to interpret a giant's statement about humans refusing to believe unless they see something and to say whether they agree or disagree, which requires considering the speaker's point. In the Tangible/Intangible activity, students must list intangibles and then think of tangible examples that could demonstrate or be evidence of each one (e.g., hugs as evidence of love, dropping a ball as evidence of gravity). Journal prompts (e.g., "Do you think it was right for the BFG to blow the Fleshlumpeater the nightmare? Why or why not?") ask students to give reasons for their positions.
Lesson 8
A Dreamy Plan
Students are asked to answer questions that require them to state reasons from the text (e.g., QUESTION #4 asks how Sophie convinced the BFG, with the explicit reason that she told him he would not have to eat snozzcumbers). QUESTION #3 asks students to describe Sophie's plan and explain why they think it will work or not, prompting students to give supporting reasons. The lesson also directs that three of the questions be used in a discussion, so students will speak and listen while offering and hearing reasons for particular points.
Lesson 10
A Breakfast Fit for a Queen
Students are asked to discuss how the butler could have come to his conclusions about table height and food amounts, explicitly identifying that the butler is using a 1:4 ratio to support his point. Question #8 and the wrapping-up prompts ask students to explain why the queen called the King of Sweden and whether the queen's response to Sophie and the Giant was believable, prompting students to state reasons for the queen's actions. The Characterizing the Queen activity requires students to select adjectives and support each with at least one example from the text, prompting students to identify evidence that justifies a claim about a character.
Lesson 11
Fighting Giants
The Skills section asks students to "Take simple notes from relevant sources such as classroom guests, books, and media sources," and to "Use multiple sources...to locate information that addresses questions," which could involve listening to a speaker. Activity 2 directs students to "Discuss why countries have armed forces" and to take notes on each branch, and Reading Questions include "Why do countries have armed forces?" (answer: to protect their country and its citizens). Activity 3 asks students to consider how the Head of the Air Force responds to the pilot, prompting attention to a speaker's response.
3: Similarities and Differences
Unit 1: Stories from Africa and Asia
Lesson 3
The Surprise
Students are asked to explain why Precious responded to Teb and Pontsho's home and the provided answer explicitly links her response to a reason (people are usually proud of their homes). Students identify scientifically accurate information about meerkats (evidence) in Question #3 and distinguish fictional traits in Question #4. Activity 4 asks students to find instances of authorial intrusion and to explain why an author might choose that device, prompting students to state reasons for an author's choices; the web link asks students to watch a documentary and discuss how filmed meerkats are similar to and different from the book, which requires citing evidence from the video.
Lesson 7
Japan
Students are prompted to read A Kids Guide to Japan and answer comprehension questions, including causes and characteristics (e.g., climate, foods, traditions). Students are asked to explain why Japan and America were at war during World War II and to discuss why the atomic bomb was so deadly, which requires stating reasons. The activities ask students to describe ways Japan and America are similar and different and to discuss how the relationship improved and how Japanese culture influenced America, providing opportunities for oral explanation and giving supporting examples.
Lesson 11
O Bon
Students are asked to read Chapter "Last Days" aloud with intonation and expression and to participate in discussion, answering three questions in their journal and using remaining questions in group talk. Question #3 explicitly asks students to state whether Sadako's mother believed she would get better and to explain why, prompting students to give reasons. Activities ask students to discuss how families remember the dead and to write journal entries or songs explaining why we remember people in particular ways, which requires giving reasons.
Lesson 12
Racing the Wind
Students are prompted to discuss and write answers to questions that ask for reasons, for example: "Why do you think the author ends the story this way?" and "Why do you think the author thought it was important for American children to hear Sadako's story?" Students are asked to answer journal questions and participate in discussions after reading the text and the epilogue, which requires them to give explanations for characters' thoughts and the author's choices.
Unit 2: Holes
Lesson 2
Camp Green Lake
Students are prompted to explain reasons in several discussion tasks: Activity 1 asks the child to explain why intelligence, perseverance, and luck are important for an inventor and to brainstorm other needs, requiring them to give reasons. Question #8 asks, "Do you think that making a bad boy dig a hole every day... Why or why not?", asking students to justify an opinion. Activity 3 asks the child why the idea "innocent until proven guilty" is important, prompting students to state reasons for a legal principle.
Lesson 13
Innocent
Students are asked orally (or in a journal) to explain character motivations, for example QUESTION #1 asks why the Warden decided not to shoot Stanley and Zero, and provides the reason that she did not want authorities to know they had been shot. Activity 2 directs students to compare the movie and book and to "discuss these possible reasons why movies based on books do not follow the book exactly," supplying a list of reasons for discussion. These tasks require students to state reasons for events or differences and to talk about reasons in discussion.
Final Project
Welcome to Camp
Students are asked to write two paragraphs describing the new camp and why it will be effective, including how activities build character and help boys become productive members of society. Students must list five ways their camp differs from Camp Green Lake and describe the importance of each difference. Students present their ideas to the family and explain why their camp will be a better place for young teenage boys.
4: Exploration and Survival
Unit 1: Abel's Island
Lesson 4
Who Is Abel?
Students are asked to provide evidence from the story to support character traits (Activity 2: Who Is Abel? and the Student Activity Page sections for Personality and Physical Appearance). Students must record words and phrases with corresponding evidence from the text and discuss whether their inferences matched author-provided information. The Skills list includes 'Draw conclusions, make generalizations, and gather support by referencing the text,' which directs students to identify supporting evidence for points they make about the character.
Lesson 8
The Dead of Winter
Students answer text-based questions asking why Abel went out in the cold and why he blamed Amanda, which requires identifying reasons for a character's actions and citing supporting details (Questions #1 and #3). Students identify how Abel adapted (stuffing holes, making a quilt, using Amanda's scarf) and are asked to find information that explains Abel's hibernation/torpor, which directs them to locate supporting evidence in the chapters. Students discuss hibernation and complete an experiment that prompts them to explain why animals hibernate and to use physiological measurements as evidence for lower metabolic activity. The skills list explicitly asks students to use oral and written language to report on a topic, implying opportunities to state reasons and supporting details aloud or in writing.
Unit 2: Pedro's Journal
Lesson 2
August
Students are asked several "Why" questions about Pedro and the crew (e.g., Why was Pedro hired? Why would Pedro turn away from his mother? Why do you think the crew says prayers?), which require them to state reasons. Students engage in oral discussion about how Columbus' crew felt the night before sailing and about crew members' feelings about the ocean, providing opportunities to state and hear reasons. The chart activity asks students to record attitudes and important events, prompting them to explain causes or motivations tied to those attitudes.
Lesson 3
September
Students answer question #3 asking why the men and Pedro do not trust Columbus, identifying specific reasons and evidence from the text (they do not believe he will find land; Pedro saw him change recorded miles). Students compare interpretations in question #4 by explaining the sailors' view of the meteor as a bad omen versus Columbus' assertion that meteors meant blessings. Discussion prompts ask students to describe sailors' fears and to talk about how knowledge changed interpretations of meteors, which requires students to state causes and supporting ideas.
Lesson 4
October
Students read journal entries for October and answer several "why" comprehension questions (e.g., Question #1 asks why Pedro enjoys the night watch; Question #9 asks why Columbus loves the natives' reactions) with provided answers that state reasons. Students record words or phrases the crew and the natives might use to describe each other in bubble maps, which elicits identifying perspectives and motives. The Wrapping Up prompts ask the child to explain how the book portrays the native people and why Pedro is uncomfortable, prompting students to state reasons for characters' attitudes.
Lesson 6
November
Students are asked directly why Columbus wanted to take the native people back to Spain (Question #1) and given the reason that they were to be converted and brought back as servants. The activities ask students to explain interactions among crew and natives and to discuss what Pedro is learning about the natives and Columbus, which prompts students to identify reasons for characters' actions. The Skills section lists 'Draw conclusions from information gathered' and 'Analyze characters,' which supports practice in identifying motives and explanations from text.
Lesson 8
The Island of the Skog
Students read The Island of the Skog aloud and answer questions that ask for causes and motivations (e.g., why the mice set off, what threatened their survival). The skills list asks students to "identify and discuss similarities and differences... and support them by referencing the text," and Activity 2 directs students to write three ways the mice showed prejudice and three ways Columbus is prejudiced, requiring citation of examples from the book. The comparing-stories graphic organizer has students record similarities and differences between two texts, which prompts them to cite supporting details.
Lesson 10
February
Students answer comprehension questions that require stating reasons drawn from the text (for example, Question #4 asks why Columbus was worried and the expected answer gives a reason). Students plan and write a firsthand report in the role of Pedro that must "explain the crew's survival, their discoveries, and what it was like to sail with Columbus," and then deliver that report orally to an audience. Students also discuss questions about the voyage in group/family conversation opportunities after reading.
Unit 3: Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH
Lesson 3
A Visit to an Owl
Students read the chapters "A Favor from Jeremy" and "The Owl" and answer comprehension questions that ask them to report what Jeremy told Mrs. Frisby to do (visit the owl) and how he said he could help (fly her to the owl and then home). Students answer a question asking why Mrs. Frisby was afraid to enter the owl's home, identifying reasons (fear of being eaten, fear of flying on Jeremy's back). Students respond to an opinion prompt asking whether Mrs. Frisby should have gone and to justify their answer, which requires giving reasons.
Lesson 4
Rats in the Rosebush
Students answer directed comprehension questions about the owl's advice (Question #1 and #3) and explain why the owl mentioned another solution (Question #2). Students describe what the owl told Mrs. Frisby about his house in Activity 3 and recount threats to Timothy in Wrapping Up. The Plot Flowchart and discussion questions require students to recall and report what the speaker (the owl or other characters) said and did.
Lesson 6
A Plan for Mrs. Frisby
Several comprehension questions ask students to state what Mrs. Frisby learned from Isabella and why the rats wanted to move the house (Questions #3 and #4), requiring students to identify information and reasons provided by a character. Question #5 asks students to judge whether the rats' plan will work and to explain why, prompting students to give reasons in support of a position. Activity 3 and the Wrapping Up prompt students to describe the rats' plan and its justification, giving opportunities to state the speakers' (rats') points and reasons.
Lesson 7
The Capture
Students are asked to answer Question #7: "Did the scientists mistreat the rats? Use evidence from the book to support your answer," which requires locating and citing supporting details. The Skills section lists "Draw conclusions, make generalizations, and gather support by referencing the text," and Activity 2 asks students to list important events and write a summary, prompting them to compile supporting details. The Wrap-Up and class discussion prompts ask students to explain how the rats were captured and to give reasons why scientists wanted rats, encouraging students to state reasons and supporting information.
Lesson 8
Life at NIMH
The lesson asks students to discuss reasons that scientists use animals for research and why it is controversial before reading, and it asks questions that prompt justification (e.g., Question #3: "How did the scientists respond... Why do you think they responded in this way?" and Question #7: "Why do scientists do research on animals?"). The wrapping up prompt asks the child to state whether the scientists were doing a good or bad thing and explain why. Several discussion and journal prompts (Question #6 and the introductory discussion) require students to articulate reasons or possible evidence for claims about the rats and research.
Lesson 10
Amazing Rats
Students answer questions that ask for reasons behind characters' actions (e.g., Questions #4 and #5 ask why the rats were building a plow and why they wanted to grow their own food). Students are prompted to discuss what they read and to "describe the Main Hall, the rats' plan, and why they have devised it," which requires stating reasons. Activity 4 asks students to write a paragraph that "support[s] her opinion with reasons" and to use linking words to connect reasons to conclusions.
Lesson 11
The Plan
The Animal Testing and Research activity asks students to read arguments for and against animal research and to interview people in the community to find out their opinions, which requires students to listen to speakers and note their positions. Students are prompted to record the positives and negatives on a chart and to write a speech that includes three reasons supporting their position, using transitional phrases to connect points.
Lesson 12
Working in the Night
Students read chapters and answer discussion/journal questions that ask for justification (e.g., "Did Billy treat Mrs. Frisby badly? How do you know?" and "Do you think the people coming to investigate the rats are from NIMH? Why or why not?"). Students are prompted at the wrap-up to "discuss ways the rats were inventive and resourceful, using examples from the text," requiring them to cite examples as support. The activities require students to summarize events and fill in a plot flowchart, which asks them to identify evidence from the story to support plot points.
Lesson 13
A New Home
Students answer direct discussion questions that require identifying characters' reasons (e.g., Question #1 asks why Nicodemus wanted Mrs. Frisby at the meeting and the expected answer states he wanted her to explain what she had heard). Students justify opinions in Question #2 (Do you think it is important... Why or why not?), which requires them to give reasons for a position. In Activity 2 students locate and record examples from the book to support literary elements, which asks them to identify textual evidence tied to specific points about the story.
